The Coast Guard Court has issued this unpublished opinion setting aside a sodomy conviction under Hartman due to the military judge’s failure to examine Lawrence v. Texas‘s impact on the case during the providence inquiry. United States v. Whitaker, No. 1366 (C.G. Ct. Crim. App. Dec. 12, 2012). Chief Judge McClelland wrote for herself and Judge John “Isn’t It Havranek” Havranek. Judge Duignan joined the portion of the opinion setting aside the sodomy conviction but dissented to the remedy adopted by the majority.